Left: The pour (cue Carly Simon's "Anticipation" ).
Right: This one is a bit overcarbonated....That minor flaw, however, didn't deter this entry from taking first place in the Light Ale Class.
Judging beers at the 2000 E.T. Barnette Homebrew Competition.
The very last beer in the first round of judging of the homebrew competition (and there was much rejoicing)!!
Judging the Best of Show round of the homebrew competition.
The Medals
Medals for the E.T. Barnette Homebrew Competition:
Best of Show - Bronze colored medallion with a blue and yellow ribbon
First Place - Bronze colored medallion with a blue ribbon
Second Place - Silver colored medallion with a blue ribbon
Third Place - Copper colored medallion with a blue ribbon
A more detailed view of the Best of Show medal.
The customized medals were produced by the Hermann Werks (http://www.the werks.net/awards1.html) for a very reasonable cost.
Overall Place |
Brewers |
City & State |
Winning Beer Style |
BOS |
Bill Brooks & Jud Robison |
Kailua, Hawaii |
Foreign Extra Stout |
2nd |
Dan Lease & John Slotterback |
Volcano, Hawaii |
Coconut Porter |
3rd |
John Metzner |
Fairbanks, Alaska |
Cyser |
Place |
Brewers |
City & State |
Winning Beer Style |
1st |
Dennis & Lisa Urban |
Anchorage, Alaska |
Belgian Tripel |
2nd |
Jud Robison & Bill Brooks |
Kaneohe, Hawaii |
California Common |
3rd - tie!! |
Rob Lowery & Ric Bills |
Fairbanks, Alaska |
American Pale Ale |
3rd - tie!! |
Matt Wootton |
Wheaton, Illinois |
Bavarian Weizen |
Place |
Brewers |
City & State |
Winning Beer Style |
1st |
Bill Brooks & Jud Robison |
Kailua, Hawaii |
Foreign Extra Stout |
2nd |
Chris Carr, Dave Almond, Diki Short, and Chad Middlesworth |
Hilo, Hawaii |
Russian Imperial Stout |
3rd |
Shawn Scott |
McAlester, Oklahoma |
Strong Scotch Ale |
Place |
Brewers |
City & State |
Winning Beer Style |
1st |
Dennis Urban |
Anchorage, Alaska |
Classic American Pilsner |
2nd |
Shawn Scott |
McAlester, Oklahoma |
Munich Helles |
3rd |
Cindy Goldstein, Wayne Borth and Mike Melzer |
Aiea, Hawaii |
Maibock |
Place |
Brewers |
City & State |
Winning Beer Style |
1st* |
--------------------------------- |
----------------------- |
------------------------------------ |
2nd |
Shawn Scott |
McAlester, Oklahoma |
Traditional Bock |
3rd |
Jud Robison & Bill Brooks |
Kaneohe, Hawaii |
Traditional Bock |
*At the judges discretion a first place was not awarded for the Dark Lager Class.
Place* |
Brewers |
City & State |
Winning Beer Style |
1st - tie!!! |
John Metzner |
Fairbanks, Alaska |
Cyser |
1st - tie!!! |
Dan Lease & John Slotterback |
Volcano, Hawaii |
Coconut Porter |
2nd |
Scott Stihler |
Fairbanks, Alaska |
Bavarian Weizen |
3rd |
Dennis & Lisa Urban |
Anchorage, Alaska |
Belgian Tiple aged on Oak |
*The winners in this Class were VERY closely ranked in terms of scores. Mere tenths of a point separated first, second and third places. Normally in the case of a tie for first place there would not be a second place prize but rather the next awarded prize would be for third place. In this particular case, the judges felt that the scores were so close as to warrant having first, second and third place prizes.
|
|
![]() |

|
|
|
|